Why Is The Black Prince Still A Controversial Historical Figure?
Conny Waters - AncientPages.com - Edward of Woodstock (1330-1376), who became known as the Black Prince was feared, loved, and hated.
As the eldest son and heir of England’s King Edward III Plantagenet, he had a huge responsibility to fight against England’s greatest enemy, France. The Black Prince was very successful on the battlefield and showed tremendous courage. He was also cunning and intelligent and did not hesitate to lure the enemy into a deadly trap if he had a chance to do so.
Left: The Black Prince being made a Knight of the Garter. Credit: Public Domain - Right: The Black Prince. Credit: Public Domain
His battles are well-documented, but there is plenty of disagreement about his personality.
Why is the Black Prince after so many years still a controversial historical figure? Was he a truly evil or good man? Was he a greedy or generous person?
English and French historians present two completely different opinions of the Black Prince, whose tomb can be visited in the Canterbury Cathedral.
How Did The Black Prince Get His Name?
Edward of Woodstock’s nickname is a subject historians fail to agree on. French historians argue that Edward of Woodstock’s nickname can be traced to his dark character. He got the name Black Prince because his soul was black. He showed no mercy and he was heartless when he and his army plundered France.
The English explain the name in much simpler terms. They maintain the name Black Prince originates from the fact that Edward of Woodstock always wore black knight armor in battle.
By doing so, he was easily recognized among other knights dressed in shiny armor.
What Kind Of Person Was The Black Prince?
It would indeed be a surprise to learn the Black Prince’s enemy praised him as a good-hearted person considering how many atrocities he committed in France. It’s no wonder French historians and writers portray the Black Prince as a pure manifestation of evil.
According to contemporary authors, the Black Prince enjoyed conquering his enemies, as well as inflicting emotional and physical pain.
His plundering in France between 1355 and 1356 gave him a very bad reputation.
The French also accuse the Black Prince of being greedy beyond imagination. He left poor peasants and workers without any belongings and ordered the burning of downtowns and cities if inhabitants refused to give him all their possessions. He treated civilians in the most horrible and cruel manner. Chronicle writer jean le Bel said all men in the city of Caen had to witness how their mothers and sisters were murdered. The wife and daughters of each man had to suffer humiliation. As if this was not enough, the Black Prince also ordered the burning of their homes.
According to French historical records, the Black Prince executed 3,000 defenseless men, women, and children in the city of Limoges.
The storming of Limoges. Credit: Public Domain
The English records on the other hand provide the modern world with a much nicer picture of Edward of Woodstock. They explain the Black Prince was a true, generous gentleman who treated people fairly and opposed all kinds of abuses and exploitation.
It was also said that he was faithful to his wife and became furious when his knights mistreated prisoners of war.
Depending on whom you listen to, the English or the French, you’ll learn about the good and bad personality of the Black Prince.
How the Black Prince was in real life is today almost impossible to determine. Ancient sources present conflicting information, are mixed up, and often filled with nonobjective personal opinions.
Written by Conny Waters – AncientPages.com Staff Writer
Updated on August 6, 2021
Copyright © AncientPages.com All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in whole or part without the express written permission of AncientPages.com
More From Ancient Pages
-
Roman Britain Executions Revealed – New Evidence
Archaeology | Aug 14, 2021
-
Humans Started Wearing Clothes 100,000 To 500,000 Years Ago
Ancient History Facts | Mar 17, 2018
-
Traces Of An Unknown Ancient Race Of Winged Beings And Other Mysterious Creatures Discovered In Japan
Civilizations | Nov 30, 2018
-
First Animals On Earth Could Have Evolved Much Earlier Than The Oldest Fossils Suggest
Fossils | Oct 13, 2022
-
A 2,500-Year-Old Marble Disc, Designed To Protect Ancient Ships And Ward Off The Evil Eye – Discovered
Archaeology | Aug 4, 2023
-
How Did Hindu God Shiva Get His Third Eye?
Featured Stories | May 13, 2019
-
On This Day In History: Sunspot Observed By Chinese Astronomers During The Han Dynasty – On May 10, 28 BC
News | May 10, 2016
-
Katana ‘Soul Of The Samurai’ – Most Famous Japanese Sword With Long Tradition
Ancient History Facts | Apr 12, 2018
-
Mysterious Underground City In Brazil Could Re-Write Ancient History – Riddle Of The 12 Men – Part 2
Featured Stories | Jan 26, 2022
-
Humans Were Apex Predators For Two Million Years
Archaeology | Oct 18, 2022
-
Unique Tomb Of Roman Noblewoman Caecilia Metella Reveals Secrets Of Ancient Concrete Resilience
Archaeology | Oct 14, 2021
-
Skull Reveals Little Foot Was Capable Of Different Head Movements Than Modern Humans
Human Beginnings | Mar 25, 2020
-
Disappearance Of The El Argar Civilization – Why Has No One Lived In The La Almoloya Region Again?
Civilizations | May 10, 2022
-
Pazzi Conspiracy – Failed Murder Attempt On Lorenzo de’ Medici Made Him Even More Powerful And Threw Renaissance Florence Into Chaos
Featured Stories | Apr 28, 2021
-
Apollo Punished Rivals For Their Extraordinary Musical Skills
Featured Stories | Apr 19, 2022
-
Controversial Tunnel Plan Near Stonehenge Gets U.K. Government Approval – Shocked And Angry Opponents Will Challenge The Decision In High Court
News | Nov 13, 2020
-
Unknown Inscription Accidentally Found In South Tower Of 13th Century Cēsis Castle In Latvia
Archaeology | Aug 18, 2020
-
Reconstructed Face Of A Young Man Who Lived Some 1,300 Years Ago
Archaeology | Jun 11, 2019
-
Playful Puck (Robin Goodfellow) – Master Of Harmless Mischief And Shakespeare’s Visit To The Magic Valley
Myths & Legends | Jun 24, 2021
-
Constantine The Great – Did First Roman Christian Emperor Use Faith For His Own Agenda?
Featured Stories | Aug 8, 2018